, Research Paper
Legal Issues Case Study for Nursing
Case 2
Nursing Situation:
Cindy Black (fictitious name), a four-year-old child with wheezing, was
brought into the emergency room by her mother for treatment at XYZ (fictitious
name) hospital at 9:12 p.m. on Friday, May 13.
Initial triage assessment revealed that Cindy was suffering from a sore
throat, wheezing bilaterally throughout all lung fields, seal-like cough,
shortness of breath (SOB), bilateral ear pain. Vital signs on admission were
pulse rate 160, respiratory rate 28, and a temperature of 101.6 ?Fahrenheit (F)
(rectal). Cindy Black was admitted to the emergency department for treatment.
Notes written by the emergency department physician on initial examination
read, “Croupy female; course breath sounds with wheezing; mild bilateral
tympanic membrane hyperemia. Chest X-ray reveals bilateral infiltrates.”
Medication prescribed included Tylenol (acetaminophen) 325 mg orally for
elevated temperature, Bronkephrine (ethylnorepinephrine hydrochloride) 0.1
millimeter subcutaneous, and monitor results.
Nurse Slighta Hand, RN (fictitious name) administered the medication as
ordered and the child was observed for thirty minutes. Miss Hand’s charting was
brief, almost illegible, and read, “Medicines given as prescribed. Cindy
observed without positive results. Physician notified.”
The physician examined the child; notes read that the child had “minimal
clearing” in response to the bronchodilator. The following medications were
then prescribed: Elixir of turpenhydrate with codeine one milliliter by mouth,
Gantrinsin (sulfisoxazole) 10
Case 3
milliliters, and Quibron (theophylline-glycerol guaiacolate) 10 milliliters.
Nurse Slighta Hand, RN charted the medications were given as prescribed.
Her note at 11:08 p.m. read, “Vomiting; unable to retain medicine. Respiration
increased (54), temperature 101.4?F (rectal); wheezing with increased difficulty
breathing.” No further notes were made regarding Cindy’s condition on the
emergency department record by the nurse, except to state that at 12:04 am,
“child released from emergency department.”
Thirty minutes after discharge from the emergency department, Cindy Black
was brought back to the hospital. This time her vital signs were absent, her
skin was warm without mottling, and the pupils of the eye were dilated but
reacted slowly to light. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation was instituted without
success, and Cindy Black was pronounced dead. Departure from professional
standards of nursing care:
In every nursing malpractice case the defendant nurse’s conduct is measured
against that of a reasonably prudent nurse under the same or similar
circumstances. Departure from the professional standards of nursing care for
the first admission to the emergency department included the following
deviations:
? Failure to assess Cindy Black comprehensively upon discharge
? Failure to assess the patient systematically for the duration of the
emergency
department visit
Case 4
? Failure of Miss Slighta Hand, RN to inform the physician that the patient
did not improve after treatment
Legal implications:
Analysis of the legal implications of the various nursing actions which
would affect the outcome of a lawsuit includes monitoring the patient’s
condition and reporting changes therein to the physician, failure to
communicate pertinent observations to the physician, and inadequate charting of
important information. “Monitoring the patient’s condition and reporting
changes therein is one of the nurse’s prime responsibilities. Nurses who fail
to record their observations run the risk of being unable to convince a jury
that such observations actually were made (Bernzweig, 1996, p. 171).” Nurses
must constantly evaluate a wealth of information and results, and as soon as
they become aware of any significant medical data, dangerous circumstances, or a
dramatic worsening of the patient’s condition, “they are required to communicate
this information to the treating physician at once. Their failure to
communicate these observations can have disastrous consequences and will
certainly increase the chances for malpractice litigation (Bernzweig, 1996, p.
177).”
Case 5
Alterations in the nurse’s behavior:
Children with respiratory problems need skilled and competent nursing care.
The symptoms of hypoxemia, a complication of respiratory problems, are often
insidious. Frequently, there is peripheral vasoconstriction with accompanying
skin color changes. Tachypnea, tachycardia, anxiety, and confusion may ensue.
It is the nurse’s responsibility to observe, evaluate, and document the
patient’s condition. In the emergency department, the nurse is the member of
the health-care team who has the greatest contact with the patient. Any
significant change in the patient’s condition, based upon nursing observation,
must be promptly communicated to the physician.
The nurse should have informed the physician promptly of the 11:08 p.m.
observations. These indicated that the child’s condition was not improving but
was, in fact, deteriorating. Before processing the discharge order, the nurse
should have communicated to the physician that the child had failed to improve
with treatment and more aggressive therapy would have been followed, possibly
including hospital admission.
Conforming to legal standards and high quality care:
Nursing malpractice exists because it is human to make mistakes under
stress, and nurses must function in a stressful environment. Nursing
malpractice can be minimized if the nurse utilizes the nursing process and
delivers patient care that conforms to the
Case 6
prevailing professional standards. Fundamental to the nursing process is a
complete initial nursing assessment and history, followed by continuous
systematic patient assessment.
The initial nursing assessment in the record was incomplete. This
assessment of the child should have included such information as follows:
? General appearance: height and weight in relation to age, development of
the body, color of the skin, posture, facial expression, presence of fatigue or
hyperactivity, gait, an presence/absence of apprehension
? Neurological status: level of consciousness, signs of menigeal irritation
? Vital signs: temperature, respiration (rate, rhythm, character), pulse
(rate, rhythm, quality), and blood pressure.
? Skin: color, temperature, presence/absence of eruptions, cyanosis,
erythema, icterus, petechiae, cysts, trauma, and scars
? Developmental status
? Disease status: breath sounds, presence/absence of congestion and/or
distressed breathing, appearance of the tympanic membranes, and appearance of
the throat, mouth and nose
In addition, the nurse’s notes for the entire emergency department
admission were inadequate and incomplete. These notes should have reflected the
execution of the physician’s orders as well as pertinent nursing observations.
Acceptable nursing care for
Case 7
children with respiratory problems involves more detailed nursing observations
than those in Cindy Black’s medical record. A nurse has the knowledge base to
make and record the following nursing observations:
? General appearance of the child (every 15 minutes)
? Body temperature (every 30 minutes)
? Pulse rate, rhythm, quality (every 15 minutes)
? Respiratory rate, rhythm, character (every 15 minutes)
? Patency of the airway (at least every 15 minutes, more if in distress)
? Blood pressure (every 30 to 60 minutes)
? Skin color and temperature (every 15 minutes)
? Level of consciousness (every 15 minutes)
? Emesis amount, character, and frequency
Summary:
Communication throughout the nursing process is crucial for the provision
of safe patient care consistent with the prevailing professional standard.
Spoken communication among all members of the health-care team, and especially
between nurse and physician for clarifying orders, planning patient care, and
reporting significant patient observations is vital to the nursing process.
Equally important is written communication by the nurse in the form of prompt
and accurate entries in the medical record.
References
Bernzweig, E. (1996). The nurse’s liability for malpractice. (6th ed.). St.
Louis: Mosby
Creasia, J. and Parker, B. (1991). Conceptual foundations of professional
nursing practice. St. Louis: Mosby
Earnest, V. (1993). Clinical skills in nursing practice. (2nd ed.).
Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott